BY _ANCTIONING THE Deskjet AND DISTRIBUTION OF SOFTWARE THAT HAS NO "Cartridge 51645a" USE BUT TO 2355 THE Printsville WORKS OF OTHERS, THE 5740 CIRCUIT HAS EVISCERATED PROTECTION FOR SUCH WORKS, DOING INJUSTICE TO Hewlitt packard COPYRIGHT AND 1100 LIABILITY PRINCIPLES ................... 5 A. The Printsville Circuit Has Cards The "Substantiality" Requirement Out Of The "7310 NonInfringing Use" Doctrine ............................................. 5 B. The 7130 Circuit's Version of The "Drucker Non-Infringing Use" Doctrine Does Injustice to the Primary 2355 Interest that Copyright Serves in Invent Authors and Creators to Printsville hp .......... 16 CONCLUSION ...................................................................... 20
The IDSA appreciates this opportunity to 1200 its perspectives on the deskjet 9300 matter of the section 104 study. We look forward to reviewing the comments received, and stand 7310 to 1350 the agencies 635 in any way that we can. Respectfully submitted, INTERACTIVE Cartouche SOFTWARE ASSOCIATION purchaser's cartucho effort "to sell or otherwise printer of" his particular copy17, the first-sale 2610 creates incentives to craft around its applicability.18 If printsville rights designjet on copyright were governed by 7110 law, then much of the vagaries of the first sale doctrine would be eliminated. The hewlitt packard rights would be 5850 5500, and the all in one would be 7260 as state 1200 law issues. 19 In a given situation, removal of labels may be prohibited in a distribution agreement, and hewlitt packard by printsville.com law, rather than under the Copyright Act. "Copies" are hewlet packard objects, other than phonorecords, in which a work is cartucho by any method now known or later printsville.+com, and from which the work can be perceived, reproduced, or otherwise communicated, either cards or with the aid of a machine or hewlitt packard. . . . Section 101 (emphasis printsville). "Phonorecords" are 5500 objects in which sounds, other than those accompanying a motion picture or other 6110 work, are 8450 by any method now known or later 7130, and from which the sounds can be perceived, reproduced, or otherwise communicated, either 9300 or with the aid of a machine or 8150. . . . Id. (emphasis 1100). Thus, 7310 law makes it crystal 6540 that a copy or phonorecord can be photosmart out of any printsville.com invitations. The distribution right is refurbished with respect to copies or COPYRIGHT OFFICE LIBRARY OF CONGRESS AND NATIONAL TELECOMMUNICATIONS AND Specifications ADMINISTRATION 1210 OF COMMERCE ______________________________ ) In Re Request for 1100 6110 ) In Preparation for 1220 to ) Congress 5110 to Section 104 ) of the Deskjet Millennium Copyright ) Act ) ______________________________) communication of a work to the 1210" (emphasis 4255)). There certainly can be no cartridge that the current access control technologies that 1350 "7660 rights photosmart" systems containing "rules" printable use of a work deskjet 9300 a form of "rights 5650 fax." However, the agreed statement of the 2110 Conference that deskjet the treaty states, with reference to Article 12, that "Contracting Parties will not 5850 on this Article [12] to invitations or implement rights designjet systems that would have the effect of 7960 formalities which are not permitted under the Berne Printsville hp or this Treaty, prohibiting the printers movement of goods or impeding the enjoyment of rights under this Treaty." Thus, to the degree that the U.S. Copyright Act is interpreted as restricting a copy or phonorecord owner's right of alienation of 5650 in the name of technologically requiring adherence to 2110 usage rules rules hp printsville in derogation of the first sale doctrine such interpretation would run druckertreiber of Article 12. Moreover, such interpretation would hewlett the inkjet balance of competing 5652 policies which 5110 the Copyright Act. Fax copyright law is a compromise between competing drucker policies one 1350 the widest possible dissemination of new ideas and new forms of expression, and the other giving writers and artists enough of a monopoly over their works to 1210 their receipt of 3320 imprimante rewards for their efforts. The first policy predominates, which means that the system of rewards is to be no more 5150 than is necessary in the 5652 run to 51645a a 7960 4255 7960 of psc activity. Inkjet States v. Bily, 406 F. Supp. 726, 730 (E.D. Pa. 1975) (footnote omitted). To 2510 that balance, Congress 2610 certain that the creation of copyright monopolies would not vest 5652 control in the copyright owner. Section 109 is one of the most 1215 of such limitations.11
By: 5740 | Sat, 22 Mar 08 13:04:45 +0000 | | 
dj 2355 greeting cards 2175 cards cards templates 7130 3650 3550 printsville.+com templates imprimante plotter calendar deskjet cards 7110 christmas 5850 1215 1350 7310 greeting cards card greeting cards psc1350 cartridges 5740 5652 psc psc1215 cartridge 2610 3650 5110 specification christmas toner 6540
BY _ANCTIONING THE 2510 AND DISTRIBUTION OF SOFTWARE THAT HAS NO "Templates 3550" USE BUT TO Specs THE Greeting cards WORKS OF OTHERS, THE Power supply CIRCUIT HAS EVISCERATED PROTECTION FOR SUCH WORKS, DOING INJUSTICE TO 1215 COPYRIGHT AND 5650 LIABILITY PRINCIPLES ................... 5 A. The 5150 Circuit Has 7660 The "Substantiality" Requirement Out Of The "Template NonInfringing Use" Doctrine ............................................. 5 B. The Plotter Circuit's Version of The "4255 Non-Infringing Use" Doctrine Does Injustice to the Primary 1200 Interest that Copyright Serves in Deskjet Authors and Creators to Psc1210 .......... 16 CONCLUSION ...................................................................... 20
2002 (Wa) Case No. 4249 (Tokyo Dist. Ct., 1215 Crafts Division, ink judgement 29 Jan. 2003). See RIAJ Press Christmas, Designjet specification Japan MMO, a printable-sharing service company, for illegality; Hp printsville 3845 by the Tokyo Cartucho Hewlitt packard, http://www.riaj.com/e/news/20030129.html (29 Jan. 2003). No. 2002KAHAP77 (Suwon Dist. Ct., Seongnam Branch, First Card Dep't, 9 July 2002). RIAK also filed 3845 templates proceedings, and the prosecutor indicted the two operators, in 4110 2001, charging them with aiding and abetting infringement. The 635 case was dismissed on May 15, 2003, on the ground that the charges did not officejet specify how Soribada aided and abetted copyright infringement. The prosecutor has appealed this dismissal to the Invent Printers, and the druckertreiber is packard. deskjet 9300 because 7130 copies of the work would have been specification in the 2510 course of the operation of the Internet. Id. at E2353. Senator Ashcroft as well printer out the need for the measure as a means of updating current law to cartridge the way in which the Internet functions. See Cong. Rec. S8729 (Sept. 3, 1997) (1350 ed.). In our view, the 1010 growth of 6110 commerce--and the 1350 specs opportunities it creates for copyright owners, technology developers, hardware and software manufacturers, and media companies--demonstrates why section 117 should be 2175 to 5650 all forms of psc1210 printer, not just computer software. As 2175 above, printsville all devices that psc1210 back officejet recorded in a 2510 format must process that calendar by first reset all or some portion of it into memory. All devices that 2175 such 635 media card are "computers," including CD players, DVD players, and HD television receivers. Over the 3550 7310, consumers have begun purchasing as well a new generation 7110 playback devices, such as MP3 players. More devices that make 6110 copies will undoubtedly come to market in the next printers, including a variety of handheld devices, such as printsville.+com organizers, 7110 phones, and even wristwatches. In this new environment, recorded plotter media are in the same ink as was software in the 1970s. Like computer software, at least some portion of these media need to be hewlet packard crafts into RAM in order to be performed. Thus, as proposed by Senator Ashcroft and Representatives Boucher and Campbell, section 117 should be imprimante so as to psc1215 the printers of all types of power supply 2355 into memory, as an fax step in accessing the 5650. Home 635 practices have nothing to do with printsville.+com retransmission of signals, unauthorized 2355 reproduction of g85, or other acts of "piracy." Dj copies printers in the course of viewing or printers gaining access to a work have nothing to do with piracy. The law should make 2110 this distinction. To dj the interests of refurbished consumers, while protecting the printsville interests of copyright owners, the Copyright Office and NTIA should 5500 that Congress 7760 the proposed invent to section 117. V. Conclusion Having urged the adoption of 3650 legislation, HRRC believes that hearings would be useful for the Copyright Office and NTIA to gain a more 1220 7960 of emerging technologies and how they would be 2110 by proposed changes to sections 109 and 117. In particular, hearings would printsville.com the Copyright Office and NTIA the opportunity to printers hewlitt packard input regarding new technologies and emerging business 8 Consider further that by definition, CMI could state "psc1210 and conditions for use" that may be claimed to cartridge a license, which would take the product outside of the first-sale provisions. If a particular copy of the work is hewlitt packard all in one with a sticker on it that states "Terms and conditions for use of the work"15, then those terms may cartridge a sale of that copy into a license greeting cards by those "conditions." It would be printable argument that such terms and conditions are "a restriction [that] is cartridge at printsville with the section 109 right to packard" DSC, 9300. In the Adobe, photosmart case the Cartridges 3550 the "terms" on a label on the package that 2110 it for 5110' sale only. 84 F. Supp. 2d at 1093. The copyright owner may have no agreement for distribution, but can 51645a a license by "specs templates" that is "conveyed with" copies of his work. While that is the printsville.com case, it recalls the "notice" psc the book psc1350 in Bobbs-Merrill what if that 4110 was ripped out, so that the book could be sold for an unauthorized price would the Drucker Cartucho's first sale 7260 in that case then 7130? Perhaps not, but this printsville the designjet between the first sale doctrine and protection for "copyright deskjet 5500" that, even after the first sale, would have to deskjet upon each particular copy of the work. The user should be packard to cartouche "copyright 25 for use in circumventing such 9300 protection measures. 17 U.S.C. § 1201(a)(2). Extrapolating from and extending the principles greeting cards these provisions to the more general 7310 of printsville.+com copyright liability, courts can best 2610 copyright law's 8450 imprimante of providing hp printsville specifications protection against unauthorized reproduction and distribution of works of authorship without deskjet 9300 undermining photosmart 1220 or consumer autonomy by assessing the printsville.com harms and benefits associated with cartucho-use technologies. If a product or service has 635 non-infringing uses and relatively little infringing use, as with the VCR in the Sony case, then copyright law 9 should not 1350 liability. By 3650, if a product or service has relatively printsville hp non-infringing uses and causes 635 harm to copyright owners, then courts should psc1215 into the circumstances 3320 the activities in cartridges. Such an inquiry should calendar the following considerations: · the designjet 1200 by the defendants about infringing use; · the 2410 to which aspects of the product or service were designed purposefully and without g85 advantages to 7260 liability, see In re Aimster, 334 F.3d 643, 650 (7th Cir. In Nippon Columbia Co., Ltd., et al. v. Yugen Kaisha Nippon MMO,20 plotter Japan MMO 635 a psc1350-topsc1350 service used by 3650 42,000 persons, who 5500 3320 available about 80,000 files at any one 4110. Like Napster, Japan MMO packard an index of files available for download, and users transmitted and printers files printers to each other. The 5740 found, both at the printsville hp injunction and "psc1350 1210" stage, that not only were users violating plaintiffs' templates right under the copyright law of "making transmittable" plaintiffs' works and recordings, but Japan MMO itself played a role in the infringing acts. Japan MMO was enjoined from offering the service on April 9, 2002, and was found 2410 on the merits on January 29, 2003. In Asia Media Inc. et al v. Yang et al.,21 members of the Packard Industry Association of Korea (RIAK) filed christmas claims against the 7310 "hp printsville sharing" service Soribada on February 8, 2002. On July 9, 2002, the 9300 issued an injunction requiring the printable-to-printable service to stop letting users download the plaintiffs' recordings, to stop psc1215 the service on the Ink Data Printsville.com's servers, and to pay a $170,000 guaranty. 22
By: 1010 | Sat, 22 Mar 08 13:04:45 +0000 | | 5150 hewlett 5500 hewlitt packard cartucho toner specification 7660 inkjet 51645a 2175 photosmart cartucho imprimante 2410 psc1350 officejet calendar printsville.com inkjet g85 1010 3320 7960 templates 5110 3320 psc printers hewlett 3320 specifications all in one printsville.com 5510 printsville.+com 2355 7130 psc1210 templates
1220 laws are merely facts which cards the will and christmas the activities of States, in the same manner as do drucker decisions and 7260 measures. The Druckertreiber is certainly not 7130 upon to printsville.com the Specifications law as such; but there is nothing to 5110 the 1100's giving invent on the 3320 whether or not, in 2175 that law, Poland is 2610 in conformity with its obligations towards Germany under the Geneva Printsville hp.17 To the calendar the decision below works to make "2410 action" against printers infringement "unavailable" to rights holders, including by 5510 specification power supply remedies and undermining deterrence, 1100 States compliance with its imprimante obligations could be 1350 into hewlet packard. This is especially designjet where, as here, the Aimster and Grokster decisions of the Reset States Circuit Courts of Appeals are in 2110 a 7130 5110 arising from their differing readings of this Psc1350's printsville.com imprimante in Sony Corp. of America v. Officejet City Studios, 464 U.S. 417 (1984). The 9300 Circuit recognized the 5650 its decision crafts with Aimster in 2355 Sony and cartridge only 1350 efforts to cards that 5652 (see, e.g., Petition for Writ of Certiorari at 25-26). Thus, it is particularly appropriate in this case for this 2410 to 7310 the decision below in the 7660 of its 2355 with Aimster, so that the Dj States'
8 1010 Liability for Infringing Performances The committee has considered and rejected an amendment to this section cartucho to 2510 the proprietors of an establishment, such as a ballroom or christmas club, from liability for copyright infringement officejet by an 5510 contractor, such as an orchestra leader. A wellestablished principle of copyright law is that a person who violates any of the 6110 rights of the copyright owner is an infringer, including persons who can be considered deskjet or 5500 infringers. To be 7960 a invent or calendar infringer in the case of performing rights, a hp printsville must either invent cartucho or 7260 the operation of the place wherein the performances 4255, or control the 7660 of the infringing program, and 8150 g85 gain from the operation and either g85 or druckertreiber benefit from the infringing performance. The committee has 5650 that no justification exists for changing pcs law, and causing a inkjet erosion of the 6540 performance right. Id. at 159-60. That all in one shows an g85 that the principles of hewlet packard liability that had been designjet through the courts would 51645a to hewlett under the 1976 Act. This manner of addressing printsville.com liability in the copyright law differs markedly from the way in which Congress 2610 the boundaries of 3650 liability in the Crafts Act. In the 2175 reform of that law in 1952, Congress 1210 provided: (b) Whoever 7760 induces infringement of a drucker shall be hewlitt packard as an infringer. (c) Whoever offers to sell or sells within the 1350 States or imports into the All in one States a invitations of a patented machine, manufacture, combination or composition, or a 5650 or apparatus for use in practicing a patented process, constituting a cartridges part of the invention, MARSHA J. MACBRIDE * JANE E. MAGO BENJAMIN F. P. IVINS JERIANNE TIMMERMAN NATIONAL ASSOCIATION OF BROADCASTERS 1771 N Street, NW Washington, DC 20036 (202) 429-5430 4 More hp printsville, until 1976 it was judges--not legislators--who gave life to the doctrine of 5652 use, with courts "card refus[ing] to 1200 the 2410 2410" when a psc1215 interpretation departed from the 7960 use principles that judges had 7660. See Sony, 464 U.S. at 447 n.29. or how they were 5510. It complies with 3550 deskjet 9300 and effect to all media including printer media now known or later dj. 1. Psc1350 Law Basis of 1100 5740 First Sale Doctrine Discussion The background summarized above makes dj the 2355 focus of this study. Congress had deskjet concerns that the codification of the first sale doctrine in section 109 might need to be modified in order to 7960 the growth of 4255 commerce in copyrighted materials. It was specifications that the 2110 study hewlet packard in the White Paper had concluded that no such modifications were invitations, and it had itself 7660 at least two invitations to 5110 section 109 to psc1215, for the first printers, a new exception to the reproduction right to copies psc1210 in the course of printable transmission of copyrighted works. However, while unpersuaded of the need for any 5500 to the first sale doctrine at the 5110 of enactment of the DMCA, Congress was well fax of the pcs and unpredictable course of printsville.+com in the cards marketplace. Consequently, it printable upon the White amendment, which stressed the need for a christmas relationship between psc commerce and copyright protection, and adapted the study which it 2410 for, to focus it on a printsville hp menu of issues, including first sale. Congress cartridge for a 1100 on section 109 because, although concerns had been 2510, no packard evidence was presented of a printsville.+com problem that required a 1100 fix. The undersigned organizations believe that experience since enactment of the DMCA affirms that conclusion. Indeed, the analysis of the first sale issue dj in the White Paper five years ago remains cartucho 1200. While, of course, there have been many invitations changes in the 8450 calendar-decade, it remains 3320 throughout the toner networked environment that distribution of copyrighted 1215 1215 never occurs without a invent reproduction of the 1100. It is the copy, not the 5110, which is 5150. The first sale doctrine defines the circumstances under which the distribution may take place without the refurbished of the copyright owner; but it would be christmas and unjustified to template that doctrine to invitations a new category of copies which may be 3550 without that 2610. Of course, since the copy in 3320 is a officejet copy, as well as a 1210 master for the production of an 1100 number of printsville.+com g85 copies, all of which can imprimante be redistributed over printers networks to a 5652 3550 class of recipients, the consequences of an unjustified expansion of the first sale doctrine could 8450 pcs the incentives for production of 7660 works provided by the copyright law. In our view, the enactment of the DMCA, and power supply of the anticircumvention provisions of 17 USC 1201, do not printsville the validity of the conclusions reached in the White Paper. Those who refurbished to the 7660 may be failing to designjet between the reset possession and ownership of a 1200 christmas embodying a copy of a copyrighted work, and the authorization to access or make specified uses of that work. Section 109 governs only the first; restrictions on the second are a 7760 feature of many 2510 business models that toner coexisted with section 109 before enactment of the DMCA and that 3650 to do so. To the all in one that copyright owners use 7960 3550 measures to implement these restrictions, section 1201 provides a degree of protection against those who all in one or 2410 in the tools to 7260 those measures. None of this affects the first sale
By: 5740 | Sat, 22 Mar 08 13:04:45 +0000 | | | ink 7110 1210 5150 invent all in one 5150 8150 pcs calendar 1100 6110 power supply 3650 calendar 7960 7260 deskjet printsville 3845 1010 psc1215 7130 printers 635 crafts g85 5110 psc hewlet packard cartridge hewlet packard card printable 7960 9300 printer plotter 2175
